
Almost a month ago I was reading an article in the New York Times about DNA testing to determine athletic ability in kids, and frankly, I was shocked.
Atlas Sports Genetics in Boulder claims that by testing the ACTN3 gene they can determine whether a child, or anyone, is best suited for speed and and power sports or endurance sports. “Finding any great Olympic champion normally takes years to determine. What if we knew a part of the answer when we were born?” their site reads. All this for just $149.
Through my experience with distance running, I believe that there is some genetic predisposition involved when it comes to athletic ability or endurance. When I was in grade school and able to beat the other kids in the mile without any advanced training or enhanced mental prowess there was something going on. Maybe it was that I’d gone through a growth spurt earlier and was just taller and skinnier, thus better suited to run long distance, or maybe it was that I’ve always been extremely competitive. Either way, once I got to an elite level of training and competition as a Division 1 college athlete, I think those people that trained harder and were fully committed to their sport were able to pass up those of us, myself included, who were more interested in having fun, genetic predisposition or not.
I guess my point is, running long distance competitively until the age of 22 defined a lot of my life, including where I went to school, the friends I made, etc., and I would have hated to have had my parents give me a genetic test at 2 years old that may have determined that I’d be better off as a soccer player. And while I understand a parent’s desire to get their kids in a sport that they have a chance at becoming a scholarship athlete, or better yet, a professional player at down the road, wouldn’t the burden of knowing you’re supposed to be great at something when you’re not or supposed to be terrible at something you love be too much for any kid to handle?
I imagine as time continues to pass and genetic tests continue to become more advanced, these type of questions will continue to arise. And before we all jump on the bandwagon and start testing ourselves and our children for everything available, maybe it’s better to take a step back and ask ourselves not only what will be gained, but also what might be lost.
Photo | The New York Times




